Memorial from the Colored Ministers of Minnesota, July 21, 1920. [Copy 1].
Type of event: Lynchings
Location: Minnesota; United States
Addressee: J. A. A. Burnquist
Addressor: Colored Ministers of Minnesota
Document date:
Document type: Correspondence
Documents: Memorial from the Colored Ministers of Minnesota, July 21, 1920. [Copy 1].
Citation:
Minnesota. Governor (1915-1921: Burnquist).
Records.
Subject Files (File 648c): Duluth Lynchings, 1920.
Memorial from the Colored Ministers of Minnesota, July 21, 1920. [Copy 1] .
Image text
At a Special Call Meeting of the
COLORED MINISTERS Of MINNESOTA, in Minneapolis, July 21, '20
A Committee was Appointed to Draft the following Memorial to
His Excellency, Hon. J. A. A. BURNQUIST, Governor of ,Minnesota.
Dear Sir:
On July 20th, a special dispatch from Duluth to the St.
Paul Dispatch states that the special district grand jury absolves Isaac McGhie,
one of the Negroes lynched on June 15th, from any part in the alleged assault on
the West Duluth girl. The report further states that McGhie was merely held as
an important witness.
The results of this grand jury investigation are
additional proof that lynch lawlessness is a mutilization [sic] of justice and
that men held under arrest should be protected from bloodthirsty mobs even if it
is necessary to shed the blood of the mob.
In the above incident, we have
the incongruous spectacle of trying a man by law after he is dead and finding
him not guilty of the crime f or which his life has been taken. Nothing more
needs to be said to prove the gross injustice of
mob rule, and that the most
drastic measures should be resorted to, both to punish the reckless taking of
human life and to compel respect for that branch of
our government which
stands for the execution of its just laws.
After satisfying the
unreasonable demands of the mob, the court also must be satisfied, Under the
circumstances, the questions arise;
How many powers are to be
satisfied?
How many terms of imprisonment are to be required, and how many
times is expiation to be made for the same crime? The alleged crime against the
Duluth girl was heinous, but the punishment already meted out is out of all
proportion to the crime. McGhie was guilty of no crime, but is dead because the
law placed him under suspicion by arresting him and failed to protect him. What
has been proven to be true in this case has been true in many other similar
cases.
[Handwritten: According to Duluth Newspaper reports,
investigations, professional testimony]
We deplore the crimes of members
of our race and desire that the proper punishment be meted out, in the proper
way, to the guilty parties, only; but no one should be punished. until his
guilt has been legally and unquestionably established.
We do not think that the attitude of the public press towards our race is just and fair, as shown in its readiness to publish and magnify the evils of the criminal class of our race, and in its indifference and silence as to the virtuous achievments [sic] of our best people. It is thus that the public receives a false and unfavorable impression of the character of our race as a whole. This attitude of the press keeps alive an ill feeling and encourages the practice of a discrimination against our people, which is wholly unjustified. No public place operated under the laws of a government should be
permitted to discriminate against any law abiding, loyal citizen of that
government. A government that stands for the elevation of one class of its
citizens and the degradation of another class is an oligarchy and unworthy of a
place among the nations . The world war was fought to put all such governments
out of existence. The practice of discrimination is contrary to the fundamental
principles of democracy and tends towards internal strife. The history of the
Colored people in America, in times of both peace and war, commends them to the
fullest measure of justice and protection of the law.
For the above
reasons, we request the governor of the State of Minnesota to use his good
offices to so change the public sentiment that our race may receive justice and
fair play at the hands of the law arid before the public bar. We feel that our
executive department should preserve the dignity of its office and maintain the
power and majesty of the law. In case a mob commits murder nothing should be
left undone to bring the guilty parties to justice and to see that they are
severely punished; for such infraction of the law is often more reprehensible
than the crime which the mob seeks to punish.
We do not think the best
citizens of Minnesota approve of lynch lawlessness, but we desire to arouse them
to an active opposition to it, in order to prevent its recurrence in the state
of Minnesota and to stamp it out in the United States of America. Our country is
cursed with no evil that is so flagrantly wrong and barbarous. It lowers the
tone of our civilization, it subjects us to the criticisms of other nations, and
it destroys respect for government.
The lesson which the world most needs
to learn and practice today is that of Golden Rate Democracy. No other principle
or policy will insure peace, strength, and permanence to our government. It is
our desire that Minnesota, both in a local and national sense shall play her
part to secure to all citizens simple justice and fair play in all industrial,
educational, and other civil matters.
The illegal and reckless taking of
human life is the worst possible form of lawlessness in a government that
teaches respect for law, and the worst insult to a flag that stands for
democracy and inalienable rights. It is also an insult to a race whose ancient
glory and achievements played such a conspicuous and leading part in the early
civilization of the world and who merits the gratitude and kind consideration of
the world rather than its comtempt [sic] and ill treatment
Respectfully,
( Rev. J. C. Anderson, Chairman